CLOSE

Phonocentrism: Ptolemy of Language

By Jolanta Lapiak

Why is worldwide society deeply phonocentric? Why is speech central to language in hearing people's thinking? Why is sign language looked down upon? Why Deaf and allies fight against phonocentric oppression for thousands of years? And on with all other related questions.

Are these questions answerable? Yes. To understand these questions, we need to look at Jacques Derrida's works and his influences.

How many of you know Aristotle? Many of you, if not the majority of you. How many of you know Derrida? Very few of you (as of this writing in the early 21st century).

If the majority of us is familiar with Derrida's work and apply it to our daily life and thinking with our language and culture, we can make a groundbreaking breakthrough.

To understand these questions above and daily thinking, we need to trace thoughts back to Aristotle or Plato.

A Brief History of Phonocentrism

Socrates -> Plato -> founded philosophy (reason, logo, etc) to separate it from literature (rhetorics, poetry, mythology, etc.)

Philosophy || literature.

Plato -> oppositions. E.g. writing -> bad / speech -> good.

True memory (internal) / writing for reminding (external).

speech -> essence of knowing / writing -> appearance

speech -> living / writing -> lifeless

That is, logocentrism emerged. So is phonocentism.

The term phonocentrism basically "positioned aural-orality at the centre of discourse on language."

Phonocentrism in part of logocentrism (defined later) is responsible for condescending writing (and sign language) as inferior to speech.

Ptolemy of Language: the Big Picture

The digital image Ptolemy of Language below created by Jolanta Lapiak describes phonocentrism in summary based on the mix of a Zen parable and Aristotlean logocentrism.

logocentrism: ptolemy of language
Image: Ptolemy of Language (2006) by ASL literary artist Jolanta Lapiak.

This image illustrates an overall concept developed to challenge phonocentrism found in daily language and thinking. For a metaphorical description of this image, see the artist's statement:

"In the image Ptolemy of Language, earth in the mouth serves as the Ptolemaic worldview, which dominated medieval thought, that positioned earth at the centre of the universe in the same way I relate it to phonocentrism/logocentrism that positioned aural-orality at the centre of discourse on language.

"The sun in one eye, like Greek lumen, represents the ancient Greek logos (speech, thought, reason, truth, etc.) which establishes its center, whereas the other eye in its blind spot pushes other languages to the margins.

"Blindness and deafness in relation to language are strangely interrelated. This shows the relationship between vision and blind in language over the period of history, in which it privileges the metaphor of blind (a metonym for word) over deafness (a metonym for visual). This has been a logocentric blind spot in language.

"In a parable, the Zen master poured tea in a cup. The guest exclaimed, "you are overflowing it." The master replied, "how can I teach you if your mind is not emptied first?" Logocentrism has been continously flowing till the works of Derrida dismantled the age-old philosophies, paving away logos."

This is, first you need to empty your conditioned mind of logocentric thinking before I can show you along the way. That is, stay open-minded and muse.

In summary, earth represents ptolemy (speech, center of language). Sun represents ancient worship of the sun, the god (logo), which leads to the blind spot (margins, the Other, minorities). Overflowing logocentrism (pouring a cup of tea and overflowing in Zen parable).

References

Lapiak, Jolanta. "Logocentrism." and/or. MFA Thesis in conjunction with MFA exhibition, 2007.

Also see how phonocentrism and sign language

Also see how logocentrism and sign language

Also see how Logocentrism: hierarchy and dichotomy

Understand basic deconstruction